Before I start, I should say I am notoriously wrong in predicting election results, so no gloating when it turns out on wednesday that Cynthia McKinney (of the Insane Woman Party) is the next president, ok?
If the polls of the past 6 weeks have any value whatsoever, Barack Obama should easily win the presidency tomorrow. Most pollsters make distinctions between “safe” states (where one candidate is ahead by more than 10 percentage points), ”leaning” states (where one candidate is ahead consistently by between 5 and 10 points), and battleground states where the lead changes or where the two candidates are within 5 points of one another. Currently, there are about 7 to 9 battleground states, representing aproximately 85 electoral votes. These states include small fish like Montana (3 votes), slightly bigger ones (Nevada, 9 votes), and two extremely big ones (Ohio and Florida, respectively 20 and 27 votes). If we look at the latest polls Obama is ahead in Florida, Ohio, Nevada, and North-Carolina, while McCain only gets Montana and North-Dakota, however all these states can swing both ways, and Obama’s lead in some of them is well within the general margin of error of polls (somewhere between 3-5 points), and the margin of error of extremely stupid pollsters (anywhere between 3 and 20 points).
So that’s the moderately good news for Democrats.
The even more moderately good news for Democrats is that, if we look at the safe and leaning states, Obama can lose all his battleground battles and still become president. Depending on which polls you buy, and which you don’t, Obama can count with relative certainty on 188 electoral votes to McCain’s 101, include the ‘leaning’ states and Obama makes it to anywhere between 277 and 300 electoral votes, putting him above the 270 line of winning the presidency. So McCain does not only have to win all the swingstates, he also has to win several states that, according to the polls, are leaning towards Obama. Is that likely to happen? No. Could it happen? Yes. Weirder election battles have been fought, and polls have been wrong. The McCain campaign seems to be banking on some sort of scenario where Pennsylvania (with 21 electoral votes a big prize, but according to all polls so far safely for Obama) is in fact very much in play, and that they are going to win there, as well as in New Hampshire (another ’safe’ state for Obama, but one that has voted Republican often in the past, and one where McCain is quite popular. All of which should just be enough to push McCain and his moose killing friend over the top.
It seems unlikely that that will happen. For one thing, Democrats have outregistered Republicans in Florida, and if Florida goes Obama, it doesn’t matter if McCain wins Pennsylvania. Secondly, all polls seem to show great discontent with the McCain/Palin ticket: as John Dickerson said on Slate, the last 159 national polls done in the last 6 weeks all show Obama ahead by 5 points or more, another poll showed enthusiasm among voters to be extremely high for the Obama ticket, but very low for McCain, voters seem to also believe that Obama is most qualified to deal with the economy and health care, and while McCain scores (moderately) better on foreign policy and terrorism, those issues are far behind the economy (57% think the economy is the major issue, 13% think Iraq is, 13% think healthcare is).
In conclusion: I’m calling it for Obama.
Swing-state derby:
McCain wins Montana, North-Dakota, North-Carolina, Ohio, Indiana, Arizona
Obama wins Florida, Nevada, Colorado and wins by 318 electoral votes